Trend Table for CMSD - CMS Energy Corporation 5.875% Junior Subordinated Notes due 2079

Current Trend Strength: Weak or Absent

Date	Grade	ADX	Long Term	Intermediate Term	Short Term	% Chg
Dec 19	A	Strong	Up	Up	Up	5.38%
Dec 18	B	Strong	Up	Up	Flat	6.85%
Dec 15	B	Strong	Up	Up	Up	6.37%
Dec 14	B	Strong	Up	Up	Up	5.72%
Dec 13	A	Strong	Up	Up	Up	6.50%
Dec 12	A	Strong	Up	Up	Flat	7.78%
Dec 11	A	Strong	Up	Up	Flat	7.16%
Dec 8	A	Strong	Up	Up	Up	7.12%
Dec 7	A	Strong	Up	Up	Up	6.94%
Dec 6	A	Strong	Up	Up	Up	7.69%