Trend Table for CMSA - CMS Energy Corporation 5.625% Junior Subordinated Notes due 2078

Current Trend Strength: Weak or Absent

Date	Grade	ADX	Long Term	Intermediate Term	Short Term	% Chg
Dec 26	B	Strong	Up	Up	Up	7.50%
Dec 22	B	Strong	Up	Up	Up	7.77%
Dec 21	B	Strong	Up	Up	Up	7.90%
Dec 20	A	Weak or Absent	Up	Up	Up	7.63%
Dec 19	B	Weak or Absent	Up	Up	Up	8.99%
Dec 18	B	Weak or Absent	Up	Up	Flat	10.66%
Dec 15	B	Weak or Absent	Up	Up	Up	9.45%
Dec 14	B	Weak or Absent	Up	Up	Up	9.54%
Dec 13	C	Strong	Up	Up	Flat	11.18%
Dec 12	C	Strong	Up	Up	Down	12.68%